My Dubiously Relevant Subject

Every year I begin my eighth grade social studies class by asking students to answer this question on an index card:

Why is social studies the most important class you will take this year?

It’s an absurd question, of course, and I learn a lot by seeing how each student tackles it. Most of them simply write out some reasons why social studies is important. Others add that other classes are equally important. A few argue that another subject trumps social studies altogether. Occasionally someone identifies it as a leading question and castigates me for pedagogic incompetence.

This year, however, I received an answer that had me laughing aloud at my desk after school:

I don’t know yet. Convince me.

Challenge accepted!

One thought on “My Dubiously Relevant Subject”

  1. Looking back at this post years later (2022), I wish I had noted down who the student was. In the years since, I haven’t gotten another response like this one. Whoever it was is in college now.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.